Tag Archives: copyright

U.S. Supreme Court: states are immune from copyright infringement liability

A new Supreme Court decision holds that states are immune from infringement suits under the United States Copyright Act, despite a 1990 law that attempted to remove states’ sovereign immunity in copyright infringement cases.

In Allen v. Cooper (decided March 23, 2020), the Court considered a case involving videos and photos of a shipwreck that the state of North Carolina published online. The owner of the copyrights sued the state for copyright infringement. The state moved to dismiss the suit on the ground of state sovereign immunity. The copyright holder countered that the Copyright Remedy Clarification Act of 1990 (CRCA) removed states’ sovereign immunity in copyright infringement suits.

In its decision, the Court noted that “a federal court generally may not hear a suit brought by any person against a nonconsenting State.” However, exceptions can be made if (1) Congress enacts “unequivocal statutory language” that takes away states’ immunity in defined situations, and (2) some constitutional provision permits the encroachment on states’ immunity. The Court found that the CRCA met the first test, but not the second test, and thus did not qualify for an exception.

In particular, the Court noted that Article I (the Intellectual Property Clause) of the U.S. Constitution gives Congress the power to secure copyright holders the exclusive right to their discoveries, but the Clause says nothing about abrogating states’ sovereign immunity.

The Court’s decision harmonizes copyright law with patent law. In a 1999 decision (Florida Prepaid Postsecondary Ed. Expense Bd. v. College Savings Bank), the Court reached the same conclusion regarding states’ sovereign immunity and the Patent Act.

New Copyright Office rule permits modification of vehicle software for diagnosis and repair, other exemptions to DMCA anti-circumvention rules

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (“DMCA”) prohibits circumvention of technical measures that control access to copyrighted works. The DMCA’s anti-circumvention requirement permits copyright holders to control how users can access digital works, and also prohibit modification of those works without permission.

In the years since the DMCA was enacted, the Copyright Office has issued several exemptions to the DMCA’s anti-circumvention requirement. In October 2015, the Copyright Office published a new rule adding several new exemptions, including: Continue reading

Are food recipes protected by copyright?

WPlatehen a chef develops a menu for a new restaurant, can the chef or the restaurant protect the recipes under copyright laws?

In a word, no. As a federal judge in Ohio recently explained, copyright protects the particular layout of a recipe in a published recipe book, or the photos that accompany the recipe. But copyright does not protect the idea or instructions that the recipe embodies.

In the case, two Cleveland restaurateurs opened a pair of restaurants serving casual fare like sandwiches, pizza, wings and salads. After three years, the founders split. The departing founder soon opened his own restaurant serving similar menu items. The remaining founder sued the departing founder, bringing claims of copyright infringement, breach of contract and misappropriation of trade secrets, among other things.

When addressing the copyright claim, the court quoted an unpublished Sixth Circuit opinion which stated: Continue reading